[AusNOG] Vyos - OSPF Flapping

Fri Jan 27 17:35:48 EST 2017

Not BFD helpfully tearing down your OSPF sessions?

Or do you need control plane policing and QoS for management data?

Kind regards

Paul Wilkins

On 27 January 2017 at 16:43, Murat Sener <Murat.Sener at premiertech.com.au>
wrote:

> Hi All,
>
>
>
> Happy new year to everyone!!!
>
>
>
> I have an odd issue with a vyos deployment running OSPF, for some reason
> the OSPF instance keeps flapping and by flapping it drops all routes then
> goes through with the SFP process this happens every 1-2 times an hour on
> both physical links facing the network we have about 4 other peers in the
> area and they run without any issues however they are cisco routers and not
> a vyos instance.
>
>
>
> I have deployed and management vyos routers for over a couple of years now
> first time every running into an issue like this.
>
>
>
> I have checked IGMP flooding I understand OSPF does not join a multicast
> group this feature is currently disabled on layer 2 has not made any
> difference.
>
>
>
> Anyone else come across this problem? I’ve run out of ideas!
>
>
>
> .199 is the virtual vyos router (loopback interface)
>
> .70 And .102 is the physically connected interfaces on the virtual firewall
>
>
>
> The rest are ip addresses of the neighbouring routers that are part of the
> same ospf area.
>
>
>
> Any feedback would be great. Please relay back offline don’t want to flood
> the list with a massive email chain.
>
>
>
>
>
> Here is a snip of the debugging:
>
>
>
> Jan 27 05:15:12 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: LSA[Type2:103.77.70.69]: 0x1893e60
> new LSA created with Link State Update
>
> Jan 27 05:15:12 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: LSA[Flooding]: start, NBR
> 103.77.70.196 (Full), cur(0x1893b50), New-LSA[Type2,id(103.77.70.69)
> ,ar(103.77.70.196)]
>
> Jan 27 05:15:12 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_flood_through_interface():
> considering int lo:103.77.70.199, INBR(103.77.70.196),
> LSA[Type2,id(103.77.70.69),ar(103.77.70.196)]
>
> Jan 27 05:15:12 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_flood_through_interface():
> considering int eth1:103.77.70.102, INBR(103.77.70.196),
> LSA[Type2,id(103.77.70.69),ar(103.77.70.196)]
>
> Jan 27 05:15:12 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_flood_through_interface():
> considering nbr 103.77.70.192 (2-Way)
>
> Jan 27 05:15:12 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_flood_through_interface():
> considering nbr 103.77.70.193 (2-Way)
>
> Jan 27 05:15:12 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_flood_through_interface():
> considering nbr 103.77.70.198 (Full)
>
> Jan 27 05:15:12 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_flood_through_interface():
> considering nbr 103.77.70.196 (Full)
>
> Jan 27 05:15:12 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_flood_through_interface():
> considering nbr 103.77.70.199 (2-Way)
>
> Jan 27 05:15:12 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_flood_through_interface():
> considering int eth0:103.77.70.70, INBR(103.77.70.196),
> LSA[Type2,id(103.77.70.69),ar(103.77.70.196)]
>
> Jan 27 05:15:12 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_flood_through_interface():
> considering nbr 103.77.70.192 (2-Way)
>
> Jan 27 05:15:12 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_flood_through_interface():
> considering nbr 103.77.70.193 (2-Way)
>
> Jan 27 05:15:12 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_flood_through_interface():
> considering nbr 103.77.70.197 (Full)
>
> Jan 27 05:15:12 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_flood_through_interface():
> considering nbr 103.77.70.196 (Full)
>
> Jan 27 05:15:12 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_flood_through_interface():
> considering nbr 103.77.70.199 (2-Way)
>
> Jan 27 05:15:12 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: LSA[Type2:103.77.70.69]: 0x1893b50
> new LSA created with Link State Update
>
> Jan 27 05:15:12 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_lsa_discard() in ospf_ls_upd()
> point 6: lsa 0x1893b50 Type-2
>
> Jan 27 05:15:12 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_ls_upd_send_queue start
>
> Jan 27 05:15:12 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: listcount = 1, dst 224.0.0.6
>
> Jan 27 05:15:12 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_make_ls_upd: Start
>
> Jan 27 05:15:12 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_make_ls_upd: List Iteration
>
> Jan 27 05:15:12 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_make_ls_upd: Stop
>
> Jan 27 05:15:12 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_ls_upd_send_queue stop
>
> Jan 27 05:15:13 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: Packet 103.77.70.196 [Hello:RECV]:
> Options *|-|-|-|-|-|E|*
>
> Jan 27 05:15:13 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: Packet 103.77.70.193 [Hello:RECV]:
> Options *|-|-|EA|-|-|E|*
>
> Jan 27 05:15:14 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: Packet 103.77.70.192 [Hello:RECV]:
> Options *|-|-|EA|-|-|E|*
>
> Jan 27 05:15:15 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: Packet 103.77.70.192 [Hello:RECV]:
> Options *|-|-|EA|-|-|E|*
>
> Jan 27 05:15:18 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: Packet 103.77.70.197 [Hello:RECV]:
> Options *|-|-|EA|-|-|E|*
>
> Jan 27 05:15:20 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: Packet 103.77.70.198 [Hello:RECV]:
> Options *|-|-|EA|-|-|E|*
>
> Jan 27 05:15:20 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: make_hello: options: 2, int:
> eth1:103.77.70.102
>
> Jan 27 05:15:20 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: make_hello: options: 2, int:
> eth0:103.77.70.70
>
> Jan 27 05:15:20 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: LSA[Type1:103.77.70.196]: 0x188aab0
> new LSA created with Link State Update
>
> Jan 27 05:15:20 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: LSA[Type2:103.77.70.101]: 0x1890960
> new LSA created with Link State Update
>
> Jan 27 05:15:20 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: LSA[Flooding]: start, NBR
> 103.77.70.196 (Full), cur(0x188c5c0), New-LSA[Type1,id(103.77.70.
> 196),ar(103.77.70.196)]
>
> Jan 27 05:15:20 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_flood_through_interface():
> considering int lo:103.77.70.199, INBR(103.77.70.196),
> LSA[Type1,id(103.77.70.196),ar(103.77.70.196)]
>
> Jan 27 05:15:20 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_flood_through_interface():
> considering int eth1:103.77.70.102, INBR(103.77.70.196),
> LSA[Type1,id(103.77.70.196),ar(103.77.70.196)]
>
> Jan 27 05:15:20 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_flood_through_interface():
> considering nbr 103.77.70.192 (2-Way)
>
> Jan 27 05:15:20 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_flood_through_interface():
> considering nbr 103.77.70.193 (2-Way)
>
> Jan 27 05:15:20 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_flood_through_interface():
> considering nbr 103.77.70.198 (Full)
>
> Jan 27 05:15:20 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_flood_through_interface():
> considering nbr 103.77.70.196 (Full)
>
> Jan 27 05:15:20 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_flood_through_interface():
> considering nbr 103.77.70.199 (2-Way)
>
> Jan 27 05:15:20 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_flood_through_interface():
> considering int eth0:103.77.70.70, INBR(103.77.70.196),
> LSA[Type1,id(103.77.70.196),ar(103.77.70.196)]
>
> Jan 27 05:15:20 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_flood_through_interface():
> considering nbr 103.77.70.192 (2-Way)
>
> Jan 27 05:15:20 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_flood_through_interface():
> considering nbr 103.77.70.193 (2-Way)
>
> Jan 27 05:15:20 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_flood_through_interface():
> considering nbr 103.77.70.197 (Full)
>
> Jan 27 05:15:20 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_flood_through_interface():
> considering nbr 103.77.70.196 (Full)
>
> Jan 27 05:15:20 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_flood_through_interface():
> considering nbr 103.77.70.199 (2-Way)
>
> Jan 27 05:15:20 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: LSA[Flooding]: start, NBR
> 103.77.70.196 (Full), cur(0x1888350), New-LSA[Type2,id(103.77.70.
> 101),ar(103.77.70.196)]
>
> Jan 27 05:15:20 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_flood_through_interface():
> considering int lo:103.77.70.199, INBR(103.77.70.196),
> LSA[Type2,id(103.77.70.101),ar(103.77.70.196)]
>
> Jan 27 05:15:20 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_flood_through_interface():
> considering int eth1:103.77.70.102, INBR(103.77.70.196),
> LSA[Type2,id(103.77.70.101),ar(103.77.70.196)]
>
> Jan 27 05:15:20 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_flood_through_interface():
> considering nbr 103.77.70.192 (2-Way)
>
> Jan 27 05:15:20 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_flood_through_interface():
> considering nbr 103.77.70.193 (2-Way)
>
> Jan 27 05:15:20 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_flood_through_interface():
> considering nbr 103.77.70.198 (Full)
>
> Jan 27 05:15:20 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_flood_through_interface():
> considering nbr 103.77.70.196 (Full)
>
> Jan 27 05:15:20 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_flood_through_interface():
> considering nbr 103.77.70.199 (2-Way)
>
> Jan 27 05:15:20 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_flood_through_interface():
> considering int eth0:103.77.70.70, INBR(103.77.70.196),
> LSA[Type2,id(103.77.70.101),ar(103.77.70.196)]
>
> Jan 27 05:15:20 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_flood_through_interface():
> considering nbr 103.77.70.192 (2-Way)
>
> Jan 27 05:15:20 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_flood_through_interface():
> considering nbr 103.77.70.193 (2-Way)
>
> Jan 27 05:15:20 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_flood_through_interface():
> considering nbr 103.77.70.197 (Full)
>
> Jan 27 05:15:20 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_flood_through_interface():
> considering nbr 103.77.70.196 (Full)
>
> Jan 27 05:15:20 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_flood_through_interface():
> considering nbr 103.77.70.199 (2-Way)
>
> Jan 27 05:15:20 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: LSA[Type1:103.77.70.196]: 0x1888350
> new LSA created with Link State Update
>
> Jan 27 05:15:20 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: LSA[Type2:103.77.70.101]: 0x1893a50
> new LSA created with Link State Update
>
> Jan 27 05:15:20 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_lsa_discard() in ospf_ls_upd()
> point 6: lsa 0x1888350 Type-1
>
> Jan 27 05:15:20 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_lsa_discard() in ospf_ls_upd()
> point 6: lsa 0x1893a50 Type-2
>
> Jan 27 05:15:20 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_ls_upd_send_queue start
>
> Jan 27 05:15:20 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: listcount = 2, dst 224.0.0.6
>
> Jan 27 05:15:20 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_make_ls_upd: Start
>
> Jan 27 05:15:20 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_make_ls_upd: List Iteration
>
> Jan 27 05:15:20 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_make_ls_upd: List Iteration
>
> Jan 27 05:15:20 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_make_ls_upd: Stop
>
> Jan 27 05:15:20 noc-fw1 ospfd[2435]: ospf_ls_upd_send_queue stop
>
>
>
> Thanks in advanced
>
>
>
> Regards,
>
> Murat Sener
>
> MESSAGE PROTECTED BY PREMIER TECHNOLOGY SOLUTIONS
> <http://www.premiertech.com.au> - POWERED BY MAILGUARD
> <http://www.mailguard.com.au/mg>.
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> AusNOG mailing list
> AusNOG at lists.ausnog.net
> http://lists.ausnog.net/mailman/listinfo/ausnog
>
>
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.ausnog.net/pipermail/ausnog/attachments/20170127/e96dbb75/attachment.html>