<div dir="ltr"><div><div><div><br></div>Just for the record - I can see all these IPs from Beijing.<br><br></div><div>We have been persistently asking for a third party, civil society involved, review process for LEA take downs/block requests.<br>
</div><div><br><br></div>Narelle Clark<br></div>President, ISOC-AU<br></div><div class="gmail_extra"><br><br><div class="gmail_quote">On Thu, Apr 11, 2013 at 3:53 PM, Danny O'Brien <span dir="ltr"><<a href="mailto:danny@spesh.com" target="_blank">danny@spesh.com</a>></span> wrote:<br>
<blockquote class="gmail_quote" style="margin:0 0 0 .8ex;border-left:1px #ccc solid;padding-left:1ex"><div dir="ltr">Hi AusNOG,<br><br>Apologies for the interruption -- I work for the Electronic Frontier Foundation in the US, and usually lurk on the NANOG lists, asking the occasional curious question about once a decade (Including "Where did Egypt just go?" <a href="http://seclists.org/nanog/2011/Jan/1416" target="_blank">http://seclists.org/nanog/2011/Jan/1416</a> and "What happens when Ripe.net doesn't pay their domain fees?" <a href="http://seclists.org/nanog/1998/Apr/50" target="_blank">http://seclists.org/nanog/1998/Apr/50</a> ).<br>
<br>My question to this even more distinguished audience is a little narrower: <br><br>We got a message from Melbourne Free University yesterday, whose site hosted at 198.136.54.104 in the US was unavailable from Optus and Telstra consumer users.<br>
<br>It looks to me that this specific IP is being patchily blackholed, mostly from Australian addresses. My working assumption is that this is due to DDOS mitigation. <br><br>The reason why Melbourne Free University got in touch with us, though, was that when they contacted their own broadband service provider., Exetel, to complain, their support eventually told them that upstream, AAPT, was blocking it due to an Australian government request, and could say no more about it. (The ticket is below.)<br>
<br>MFU is understandably a bit disturbed by such a statement from their ISP, as are we. I *am* at this stage assuming miscommunication rather than government action. I've reached out to AAPT and Exetel, and been banging on BGP looking glasses and traceroutes all day, and not getting much response, so I thought I'd broaden out the query and ask you all:<br>
<br>1) Is anyone here blackholing 198.136.54.104 or the /20 (though I've seen people being able to reach .103 and .105 fine, but lose 104) for DDOS or other operational reasons?<br><br>2) Hypothetically, can anyone suggest a Federal court order or government process that would lead to such a blackhole for *non*-operational reasons?<br>
<br>Thank you for your attention -- I hope your curiousity is as piqued as mine was.<br><br>d.<br><br>> Please note that we regret to inform that the IP address has been blocked<br>> by Australian authority for undisclosed reasons.<br>
><br>> As per our supplier, due to the legal department our supplier is unable to<br>> share any information regarding the blocking of the IP address. Therefore<br>> we are not able to provide the details regarding who has blocked the IP or<br>
> why because the supplier wont provide these info.<br>><br>> Also note that our supplier is unable to have this IP unblocked.<br>><br>> Level 1 - Network Support Engineer<br>> Exetel Pty Ltd<br>
<br><br> Here is the route taken by an Exetel consumer subscriber using the AAPT network attempting to access the site.<br> <br> > $ traceroute <a href="http://www.melbournefreeuniversity.org" target="_blank">www.melbournefreeuniversity.org</a><br>
> traceroute to <a href="http://melbournefreeuniversity.org" target="_blank">melbournefreeuniversity.org</a> (198.136.54.104), 64 hops max, 40<br> > byte packets<br> > 1 XXXXXXXXXXXXX (192.168.1.254) 1 ms 1 ms 1 ms<br>
> 2 <a href="http://XXX.XXX.96.58.static.exetel.com.au" target="_blank">XXX.XXX.96.58.static.exetel.com.au</a> (58.96.XXX.XXX) 18 ms 19 ms 18 ms<br> > 3 <a href="http://33.2.96.58.static.exetel.com.au" target="_blank">33.2.96.58.static.exetel.com.au</a> (58.96.2.33) 19 ms 18 ms 19 ms<br>
> 4 <a href="http://pe-5017370-mburninte01.gw.aapt.com.au" target="_blank">pe-5017370-mburninte01.gw.aapt.com.au</a> (203.174.186.73) 24 ms 20 ms<br> > 20 ms<br> > 5 <a href="http://te3-3.mburndist01.aapt.net.au" target="_blank">te3-3.mburndist01.aapt.net.au</a> (203.131.61.30) [MPLS: Label 190 Exp 1]<br>
> 35 ms 35 ms 31 ms<br> > 6 <a href="http://te0-3-4-0.mburncore01.aapt.net.au" target="_blank">te0-3-4-0.mburncore01.aapt.net.au</a> (202.10.12.15) [MPLS: Label 17412 Exp<br> > 7 <a href="http://bu2.sclarcore01.aapt.net.au" target="_blank">bu2.sclarcore01.aapt.net.au</a> (202.10.10.74) [MPLS: Label 16702 Exp 1]<br>
> More labels 49 ms More labels 32 ms More labels 31 ms<br> > 8 <a href="http://te2-2.sclardist01.aapt.net.au" target="_blank">te2-2.sclardist01.aapt.net.au</a> (202.10.12.2) [MPLS: Label 895 Exp 1] 31<br>
> ms 32 ms 33 ms<br>
> 9 * <a href="http://po6.sclarbrdr01.aapt.net.au" target="_blank">po6.sclarbrdr01.aapt.net.au</a> (202.10.14.3) 30 ms *<br> > 10 * * *<br> > 11 * * *<br> <br> Here is the route taken by a Telstra subscriber in Brisbane.<br>
<br> > $ traceroute to <a href="http://www.melbournefreeuniversity.org" target="_blank">www.melbournefreeuniversity.org</a> <<a href="http://www.melbournefreeuniversity.org" target="_blank">http://www.melbournefreeuniversity.org</a>> (198.136.54.104), 30 hops max, 60 byte packets<br>
> 1 10.205.XX.XX (10.205.XX.XX) 8.936 ms 8.989 ms 8.977 ms<br> > 2 58.160.XX.XX (58.160.XX.XX) 9.349 ms 9.425 ms 9.482 ms<br> > 3 58.160.XX.XX (58.160.XX.XX) 9.705 ms 9.765 ms 9.753 ms<br>
> 4 172.18.241.105 (172.18.241.105) 12.691 ms 12.817 ms 12.705 ms<br> > 5 <a href="http://bundle-ether10-woo10.brisbane.telstra.net" target="_blank">bundle-ether10-woo10.brisbane.telstra.net</a> (110.142.226.13) 15.426 ms 15.482 ms 14.644 ms<br>
> 6 <a href="http://bundle-ether3.woo-core1.brisbane.telstra.net" target="_blank">bundle-ether3.woo-core1.brisbane.telstra.net</a> (203.50.11.52) 17.872 ms 12.953 ms 13.940 ms<br> > 7 <a href="http://bundle-ether11.chw-core2.sydney.telstra.net" target="_blank">bundle-ether11.chw-core2.sydney.telstra.net</a> (203.50.11.70) 25.653 ms 26.135 ms 26.054 ms<br>
> 8 <a href="http://bundle-ether1.pad-gw1.sydney.telstra.net" target="_blank">bundle-ether1.pad-gw1.sydney.telstra.net</a> (203.50.6.25) 27.017 ms 27.078 ms 27.072 ms<br> > 9 <a href="http://gigabitethernet0-2.pad-service2.sydney.telstra.net" target="_blank">gigabitethernet0-2.pad-service2.sydney.telstra.net</a> (203.50.6.70) 24.064 ms 24.129 ms 24.111 ms<br>
> 10 * *<br> > 11 *<br> > 12 *<br> > 13 *<br><br><br></div>
<br>_______________________________________________<br>
AusNOG mailing list<br>
<a href="mailto:AusNOG@lists.ausnog.net">AusNOG@lists.ausnog.net</a><br>
<a href="http://lists.ausnog.net/mailman/listinfo/ausnog" target="_blank">http://lists.ausnog.net/mailman/listinfo/ausnog</a><br>
<br></blockquote></div><br><br clear="all"><br>-- <br><br><br>Narelle<br><a href="mailto:narellec@gmail.com" target="_blank">narellec@gmail.com</a>
</div>